Showing posts with label Steakhouse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Steakhouse. Show all posts

Saturday, November 8, 2008

Strip Steak - 11.08.08



Location -
13 E.12th Street, New York / Greenwich Village
Style of Cuisine - Steakhouse

TOTAL SCORE - 40
Food - 19 (outstanding across the board)
  • 20oz. New York Strip: perfect wet-aged flavor, well-seasoned, little fat, perfect charring, outstanding flavor all around
  • Pan-Seared Scallops - the only disappointing dish but still good, no presence of truffle (which was in the description), sauce a little one-dimensional
  • Black Truffle Creamed Spinach - outstanding, perfect consistency, apparent truffle flavor but not overpowering, over-priced based on portion size at $12
  • Crisp Goose Fat Potatoes - good but a little heavy, a bit bland internally
  • Creamed Corn with Pancetta - very good, a little bit more runny than I would've preferred but still delicious
  • Glass of Coppola Claret - delicious
  • Glass of Bearboat Pinot Noir - very good
Service - 8 (solid, but nothing special)
Atmosphere - 6 (poorly lit, mildly kitschy, boring lay-out)
Value - 7 (delicious, but over-priced sides)

OVERVIEW -
Alright, so I've heard enough people stomping about this place that I had to give it a go.  Let me say, it lived up to it's billing and then some.  I'll just cut to the chase and say that everything I put in my mouth from the free bread to wet-aged 20oz strip steak ranged from really good to "wow."  It was one of the best meals I've had in a very long time.

I've never been a huge fan of the banquette seating where the two-tops are so cramped together the host almost needs assistance pulling out the table so your guest can wedge themselves in (especially when there were other tables available which would've allowed them to seat every other one and provide a bit more privacy - albeit temporarily).

Look, I'm not going to waste cyberspace looking for things to be critical of.  It was delicious and I'm already missing some of the dishes... what more can I say?

Contact Info - www.striphouse.net


 


Friday, November 7, 2008

Peter Luger Steak House - 11.01.08



Location - 178 Broadway, Brooklyn, New York
Style of Cuisine - Steakhouse

TOTAL SCORE - 34
Food - 17 (very good porterhouse and great cheesecake)
  • Porterhouse for 2: Massive, delicous, great flavor & charring
  • Side of Creamed Spinach: A complete joke. Tasted like canned spinach with no other discernable flavors (except water).
  • French fries: Average
  • Cheesecake: Oustanding. Rich, fluffy, great crust.Best ever.
  • Pecan Pie: Average. Served with an obscene amount of whipped cream on the side ("schlag" they call it) - way over the top.

Service - 6 (slow, unattententive, but friendly)
Atmoshpere - 4 (no excuse for bright lights and dull)
Value - 7 (the prices were very fair considering portion size)

OVERVIEW -
Don't believe the hype. I know New Yorkers seem to suck at the tit of Peter Luger, but give me a break. It was a very good porterhouse - but nothing I could not find at a dozen other steakhouses in the country (many of which can be found in NYC, btw) and the sides (all 3 of them) ranged from shitty to ok. And no, I am not someone who thinks a steakhouse needs to filled with pomp, circumstance, and 39 different menu options. I just think that if you're playing the minimalist, "quality versus quantity" game, then the few offerings you provide had better be fucking stellar. The cheesecake I must say, however, was hands down the best I've ever had.

As for the place itself, Kitschy would have been a vast improvement. Their German-American vibe falls painfully short when the lights (which are set on "10" at 8:00 pm) shine so bright that you can actually read the "Made in the USA" stamp on the Beer Steins.

All-in-all, it was worth the visit, and the porterhouse was very good. But New Yorkers, like metro-centrists everywhere, seem to bestow their local eating institutions with delusions of grandeur rarely befitting.

Contact Info - http://www.peterluger.com/

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Kobe Club - 08.08

Location -
Style of Cuisine -

TOTAL SCORE -
Food:
Service:
Atmosphere:
Value:

OVERVIEW -

Contact Info -